At today's price, Goldman Sachs's stock is priced as if it can sustain a return on equity of about 22.9% forever — 1.7 times its 5-year average of 13.7%. The catch: the most recent quarter's ROE was 23.5%, essentially matching what the price already requires, so the real question is whether that's a new normal or a temporary peak.
Why a bank isn't valued on free cash flow
At its current price, GS is priced as if it will sustain a ~22.9% return on equity forever.
Actual ROE over the past 5 years ranged from 7.5% to 23.0%, averaging 13.7% — though the most recent quarter (Q2 2026) came in at 23.5%, almost exactly matching what the price requires.
22.9% return on equity needed vs. a 13.7% five-year average
| Required ROE (price-implied) | 22.9% |
| 5-year average | 13.7% |
| 5-year low (2023) | 7.5% |
| 5-year high (2021) | 23.0% |
| Q2 2026 (annualized) | 23.5% |
How the discount rate changes the required return, from 17.5% to 22.9%
| COE | Required ROE |
|---|---|
| 8% | 17.5% |
| 9% | 20.2% |
| 10% (base case) | 22.9% |
| 11% | 25.7% |
| 12% | 28.4% |
A volatile securities firm like Goldman is often assigned a somewhat higher cost of equity (10-11%) than a stable large-cap bank (8-9%) — and that single choice swings the required ROE from 17.5% to 25.7%.
What would change Goldman's 22.9%
- Lowering the long-term growth rate (g) from 2.5% to 1.5% actually raises the required ROE, from 22.9% to 24.7% (a smaller-denominator effect).
- Using year-end-2025 book value per share ($357.60) instead of the latest quarter's ($367.67) raises the P/B multiple to 2.80x, nudging the required ROE up to 23.4%.
- Switching to total shareholder returns (dividends + buybacks) as an FCF proxy and solving with the standard growth-rate reverse-DCF model gives a completely different picture: at COE 10%, the required growth rate is just 5.8% — well below the actual 3-year growth rate in shareholder returns (35.8% a year). In other words, "how much better does it need to get" (the ROE lens) looks demanding, while "how much more does it need to return to shareholders" (the cash-flow lens) looks modest — the fact that the two lenses disagree is itself a useful signal.
The math behind 22.9%
Inputs, sources, model assumptions, and the calculation
- Share price$1,001.95 — TradingEconomics, Aug 20, 2026 close
- Shares outstanding291,171,408 — 10-Q Q2 FY2026 cover page, Jul 17, 2026
- Book value per share (BVPS)$367.67 — 10-Q Q2 FY2026 balance sheet, Jun 30, 2026
- Cost of equity (COE)10% base case (8-12% tested)
- Long-term growth rate (g)2.5% — roughly long-run real GDP growth
Why not standard FCF: the 10-K FY2025 consolidated cash flow statement shows net income +$17,176M vs. operating cash flow -$45,154M (2024: -$13,212M; 2023: -$12,587M). Balance-sheet items unrelated to underlying earnings power — trading assets (-$69,866M), trading liabilities (+$57,560M), collateralized transactions (-$12,891M) — dominate the reported cash flow. FCF is structurally negative and distorted here, so a bank-valuation alternative was used instead.
Formula: P/B = (ROE − g) / (COE − g) → ROE = g + P/B × (COE − g). P/B = $1,001.95 / $367.67 = 2.725x. With g=2.5%, COE=10%: required ROE = 2.5% + 2.725×(10%−2.5%) = 22.9%. This reformulates a dividend-discount model in terms of return on equity — a standard approach in bank and broker-dealer valuation.
Cross-check: Goldman returned an average of 87.5% of net income to shareholders (dividends + buybacks) over the past three years (60% in 2022, 110% in 2023, 83% in 2024, 98% in 2025). Using that total shareholder-return figure as an FCF proxy in the standard 10-year-plus-terminal two-stage model and solving by bisection: with CF₀ = 2025's total return ($16.78B) and market cap $291.7B (2026-07-17 basis), the implied g ≈ 5.8% at COE 10%. Using the trailing-3-year average CF₀ ($12.66B) instead shifts that to g≈9.6% — buybacks are discretionary and swing more year to year (2025's figure ran +32.6% above the 3-year average), so this alternate metric carries more noise than the ROE-based model.
Historical benchmarks: ROE 23.0% (2021), 10.2% (2022), 7.5% (2023), 12.7% (2024), 15.0% (2025); Q2 FY2026 annualized ROE 23.5%; 3-year net income CAGR (2022→2025, off the cyclical low) +15.1%; 4-year BVPS CAGR (2021→2025) +5.9%.
Limits of the GS number
- This isn't a fair-value price target — it only shows what the current price already assumes.
- Change the cost of equity, the growth rate, or the FCF proxy used for the cross-check, and the result moves substantially — see the sensitivity table and "what would move it" section above.
- Banks and broker-dealers don't fit the standard FCF reverse DCF, so a ROE-based model was substituted here — that substitution is itself a judgment call, and other analysts might choose differently.
- Whether the required ROE is realistic depends on whether the current run of record results — and its dependence on the AI infrastructure investment cycle, covered in the story piece above — is durable, not on this math alone.
- Any investment decision, and its outcome, is your own responsibility.
What we'd watch next
These three checks would show whether this read is holding up. They are prompts for your own follow-up, not predictions.
- ROE vs. 22.9%The price needs about 22.9% forever; the five-year average was 13.7%, the latest quarter 23.5%.
- Peak or new normalThe whole question is whether high returns persist through a cycle.
- Cost of equityAt 8% the required ROE is 17.5%, at 10% it is 22.9%. Choose carefully.
How this number is built, and how banks, REITs, and negative cash flow are handled: see our methodology.
Frequently asked questions
Why does this use return on equity instead of free cash flow?
Goldman Sachs's balance sheet makes a standard free-cash-flow reverse DCF meaningless, since it's a securities firm, not an operating company — so this analysis uses the bank-valuation model investors actually rely on: reverse-engineering the return on equity the stock price already assumes.
What ROE does GS's stock price assume?
At today's price, Goldman Sachs's stock is priced as if it can sustain a return on equity of about 22.9% forever — 1.7 times its 5-year average of 13.7%.
Is Goldman Sachs's current ROE close to what the price requires?
Yes, unusually so — the most recent quarter's ROE was 23.5%, essentially matching the ~22.9% the price requires, so the real question is whether that's a new normal or a temporary peak.